About the Show       Bio            Blog        Podcast

VIDEO: What does the PQ have in common with this screaming lady?

Posted By: Dan Delmar · 2/13/2013 5:38:00 PM

A follower on Twitter sent me the strange video below of a woman on the Métro screaming at fellow passengers and giving them the middle finger for daring to address her in a language other than French; it's a safe assumption that the offending tongue was English.

Now, at first glance, you might think that it's just a morbidly fascinating, potentially viral video of a disturbed individual incoherently ranting about nonsense on public transit when she should be getting treatment in a mental institution (thanks again for the deinstitutionalisation plan, Brian Mulroney). But I choose to read a bit more into this.

My friend Barbara Kay recently argued that "mentally disturbed people often take 'reasons' for their paranoia from vibes in the general atmosphere." I knew Barbara was onto something, but I wasn't totally convinced of her "vibes" argument until I saw this video.

The woman in question repeats a slogan that is frequently used by Parti Québécois (PQ) leaders and other ultranationalists, and is used in a long-standing government campaign (supported by the Quebec Liberal party as well) to encourage French in the workplace: "Ici, c'est en Français que cela ce passe!" There are variations to the oft-used slogan, from the more colloquial "ici, c'est en français que ça se passe" to the more business-oriented "ici, on commerce en français." The latter is the slogan created by marketing firm Bleublancrouge for the government.

If politicians, leaders, repeat slogans enough, they start being adopted by their flock, and the sheep start seeing the spin as reality. Of course, there are many languages used in business in Quebec and no amount of government intervention (short of a genocide) will ever change that. But the "ici, c'est en Français" line sounds strong and definitive, and reaffirms a sense of pride that insecure nationalists have about their language (which, statistically, has been doing just fine, but that's besides the point).

This screaming woman on the Métro is only repeating what PQ and Liberal governments have been promoting for years. Her tone is loud and aggressive, but having government tell the population, "here, we speak French," isn't exactly delicate, diplomatic or the least bit welcoming either.

If, for instance, this woman were to lunge at an Anglophone passenger, I wouldn't blame the PQ for that. Fostering a climate of intolerance toward linguistic minorities isn't quite as irresponsible inciting violence against those minorities, but it certainly doesn't help. For that reason, I rejected the Société Saint-Jean-Baptiste's argument that I helped foster a climate of hate that led to Richard Henry Bain's election night shooting, which killed one man. Even if I were hateful toward Francophones - a charge I will always vigorously deny - no reasonable person could accuse me of having blood on my hands because of the actions of a lone, deranged man.

When government enacts policies that are inherently repressive toward whole groups of people, however, that is an action that can have real-world implications. It legitimizes, more than a radio host or newspaper columnist ever could, the demonization of Anglos and other linguistic minorities, and discourages civil exchanges between citizens with equal rights. 

This video isn't shocking - we've seen countless reports of such anti-Anglo incidents. Instead, it is simply honest. It's an honest reflection of the nationalist discourse in Quebec, which is fueled less by a sense of pride in the Québécois culture and the French language than a disdain for English and the perceived threat that it poses to this society. 

It may seem ridiculous, at first, to suggest that a screaming woman on the Métro could have anything in common with Premier Pauline Marois and fellow language zealots. But when you examine the current political climate in Quebec, it is clear that the only thing separating the screaming lady from our nationalist leaders is a little tact and a big wardrobe allowance.

 

Leave a comment:

showing all comments · Subscribe to comments
Comment Like
  • 15
  1. Deborah Ann posted on 02/13/2013 07:46 PM
    Disturbing. Ever since this government got in we see hatred which we had not seen since the 80ies. Very sad to be living through this.
  2. Irish posted on 02/13/2013 07:54 PM
    How Sad! To think that this is 2013 and there are poeple in that mind set still among us. Whar a reflection of the type of people that want to run our province. An embarassement to Canada.
    1. Theo posted on 02/16/2013 06:17 PM
      @Irish The screaming lady is an OLD lady with the OLD nationalist mindset from 40 years ago. Soon these people will die off, as will Marois and Parizeau. Younger generations have grown up in a different kind of Quebec where the French language dominates. Hopefully they are more secure and open-minded about accepting others.
  3. Nicole MacKenzie posted on 02/13/2013 08:55 PM
    Check out the site "quebec francais". Today I posted a comment, in French, but you won't see it because they removed it. I've been blocked. Anyone who "liked' my comment and made a subsequent comment had their words "removed". I was moved to write on their site because they published a list of people, actual people, who had voiced dissent about their page/opinions/etc. and they published the list of those they blocked. Does that sound familiar? Then I received in-box messages that were hateful and 4 phonecalls. Shortly afterwards, they posted a lovely opinion, with pictures, explaining the difference between a McGill student and a rat - the rat was the preferred creature. This is a hate-page and FaceBook will not remove it. We are moving into dangerous territory in this province and I don't care how many letter or phone calls I get, I'm not putting up with it anymore.
  4. RykE posted on 02/13/2013 09:55 PM
    Well stated Dan. Good pick up on the effects of programming. They may suck as politicians, but they got the high score on their communication efforts...

    I would be dollars to doughnuts that most of the supporters of a sovereign Quebec never had a clue that they were passively being programmed... God know what other messages we have all been exposed to which now shape our views, and beliefs.
  5. Alan Munroe posted on 02/13/2013 09:57 PM
    I like all of this stuff. My business thrives. As virtual sales exec I am the Anglophone doorman for a number of French companies. Put yourself in a box beholding to the Anglo's who stay. I love it!

    And by the way we're already gone. Does the term .com, outsourced talent, international web platforms mean anything? You are only going to get what we allow.

    We own it. We dictate the language. It's our own business not you. And if my customers are Chinese ...so are the signs, and the spoken language. OTHERWISE I WILL SUE THE GOVERNMENT FOR BUSINESS LOSSES, DAMAGES AND INCONVENIENCE.

    I think September 2014 the PQ will fall from grace and their deception unveiled.
    Most of my French friends are really scared and uncertain about their future here in Quebec. And this saddens me.
  6. FXJ posted on 02/13/2013 10:58 PM
    In Ontario and Alberta I've heard many people state that we are in an English-speaking country (as opposed to a bilingual country). I haven't been in the other provinces much so I haven't heard it elsewhere yet, but I'm sure it's the same everywhere.

    If as you claim it's climate of "vibes" that are responsible for this, then you have to admit that this climate exists throughout the country, which means that even after many centuries, the assimilation tendencies of the English have not subsided. If francophones did not feel their culture and language were so threatened in this country, policies and "vibes" in Quebec would not be what they are.

    Attempts by the English to dominate the French predate the PQ, so if you want to lay blame on someone for the "vibes", blame the ones who started the fight!
    1. Simon Templar posted on 02/14/2013 07:44 PM
      @FXJ I would, but they've been dead for almost 270 yrs. Je me souvien indeed.

      And nowhere else in this country is the government forcing you to speak a language, forcing you to do business in their language, only accepting immigrants who speak their language, and telling whomever will listen "ici on parle francais", whether you are speaking to them or not. There is a big difference.

      I don't care how threatened you feel your language or culture is, you do not get to trample my rights.
  7. Robbie Key posted on 02/14/2013 04:45 AM
    Wow!

    I find it insanely disturbing that a persons mind can be that polluted. I've been here for 30 years now, moving from the East Coast, and my friends and family, daily, ask me why I stay?

    After seeing more and more of this retched spew, it's time to reflect on what they, that care, are asking!

    With an obvious open nationalistic agenda, alongside a huge platform to showcase it, the PQ are slowly destroying a society that I became part of, yet no longer feel akin to.

    If this woman put as much energy and passion into other avenues of her life, she most likely would be in a happier place. Speaking of Avenues and happier places, I've got to find one myself....in another province!
  8. LMAO posted on 02/16/2013 06:26 PM
    Yes they both rant things to the general public at large that only they can make sense of.
  9. Le Québécois posted on 02/17/2013 07:20 PM
    I'm sure english media all over Canada will have a field day highlighting how backward we all are in Québec when somebody makes a scene about our language.

    We all know only french quebekers are that crazy ( remember Mr. Bain ? )

    But when an allophone makes a scene at a SAAQ office by "explaining" to us what Canada is and implicitely reminding us how conquered nations do not deserve to have a melting pot of their own he is an "oppressed canadian".

    Barbara Kay is telling the national post that she feels "physically in danger" in Québec... (after having to retract her ridiculous claim on french TV afterwards)

    Meanwhile our Premier was in real physical danger and almost got assassinated...


    When the double standard will finally drop...

    The two solitudes will vanish...
  10. Ben posted on 02/19/2013 03:45 PM
    She's just the flipside of an angryphone wild-eyed rants. Wouldn't blame Anglo leaders for those, would we?
    1. Le Québécois posted on 02/20/2013 11:52 AM
      @Ben No, it's different.
      Because angryphones actually get generous amounts of money from the federal to do that.
      She doesn't... :)
showing all comments