Clarifying the language of signs

Posted By: Shuyee Lee · 6/20/2012 1:30:00 PM

Today is the deadline for businesses with English trademark names to say whether they'll add a French description to their signs, following a letter sent by the province's language watchdog. This was a story that CJAD first brought to you a few months ago.

But it looks like some companies may be ready to take the case to court.

The Retail Council of Canada received legal advice that the language watchdog OQLF is misinterpreting the provisions of Bill 101 allowing English trademarked names such as Canadian Tire, Toys R Us and Future Shop. They are thinking of contesting the issue in court.

Nathalie St-Pierre, Quebec v.p. for the Retail Council of Canada, said they'd like the language watchdog OQLF to clarify the Bill 101 regulation, asking the courts for a ruling if necessary.

"We're wondering why it is that now in the last few months there's a need to add a French generic to a trademark which is protected by law and excluded from the Charter," St-Pierre told CJAD News.

OQLF spokesman Martin Bergeron said their focus has shifted only now because of other priorities in the past, adding they have no problem going to court.

"We are very at ease with our iinterpretation, we think it's solid," Bergeron said in an interview with CJAD News.

"We don't want to go that way but in 2% of the cases of complaints we receive, we have to. In 98% we can make changes without going to court," he said.

"What we want in the end, is to have the French face of Montreal, not that companies face fines."

Those fines range from $1500 to $20,000, plus their francization certificate would be revoked.

Bergeron said some companies have said they'd comply and others said they'd check with head office.

Photo: Joe Raedie/Getty Images

Leave a comment:

showing all comments · Subscribe to comments
Comment Like
  • 22
  1. wendy posted on 06/20/2012 02:54 PM
    ENOUGH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    This is 2012!! stop being so FKNing small mdd ignorant morons!!
  2. Thomas posted on 06/20/2012 02:59 PM
    This is just more stupidity from the OQLF, wasting more tax payer's money. Having an english company name does not mean that Francophones will get confused and forget how to speak French. If that were the case, then one could argue that english signs means that Italians or Greeks would get confused and forget how to speak their native languages too.

    I sincerely hope that these companies decide enough is enough and just close all their stores and offices in Quebec and go to another province or country. This would serve Quebec right. Enough of this nonsense.
  3. anonymous posted on 06/20/2012 03:56 PM
    Get rid of Bill 101.
    1. chuck posted on 06/27/2012 06:09 AM
      @anonymous They can't as language is the sacred cow and they perceive bill 101 as protecting it. If anything the OQLF is just getting going.
  4. Joe posted on 06/20/2012 04:05 PM
    The Quebec government is simply trying to intimidate these companies.
    They do not have a case here.Trademarks are indeed exempt and would require federal government involvement.On top of it, there would be international trademark law to consider.
    It is pathetic how the city of Montreal pretends to be French by law.
    It is an embarrassment for all of Canada that Bill 101 exists.
  5. Harry posted on 06/20/2012 04:19 PM
    Hope some of these companies pack it in and all the FRENCH people working there lose their jobs. Talk about cutting off the hand that feeds you. Teach them a lesson for their ignorance. More than 9/10ths of the educated public know what these stores sell. To force companies that invest money coming here and to thank them with draconian laws, most notably at election time (notice the time of the enforcement and Charest's weakness in the French vote) of this well past its time law) is a slap in the face of these companies. Shame on Charest for even letting OLF exist just for votes. And shame on use for voting the very person that keeps putting the screws to us.
  6. KieSeyHow posted on 06/20/2012 04:21 PM
    What if their next step is that they want everyone in the province of Québéc to change their names to French ones? Perhaps, you will no longer be allowed to get a driver's license unless you have a French name. If you change the name of a business to a French one, all the legal documents no longer apply, the address will not work, any Internet searches do not work when looking for the company. Are these people possessed with any semblance of common sense at all? This is not about culture, it is about sociopathic control freaks with a low IQ.
  7. alrev posted on 06/20/2012 09:29 PM
    How about signs that say on parle anglais ici!
  8. JS posted on 06/20/2012 10:56 PM
    Well maybe a lot of peoples have right here but if you want to do business, you can change a little. Look Staples = Bureau en Gros, they won. future Shop can change for something else. Anyhow, with 300 millions of english in south, 30 millions at the west, 1 millions to the east, I don't care about the law of the french peoples that I like to lived in quebec no matter what anD i don't think this law is going to change my language. I speak both language and i'm just better to understand many culture.

    For sure, don't touch to the familly name like Mcdonald's, Molson, etc. with this law.

    finally, I prefer the little french canadians and this little law than a muslim who wants to control the world.
  9. Terry posted on 06/20/2012 11:44 PM
    Time the quebec government follows the lead of the federal government and cuts out unnecessary government departments. The OQLF should be the first to go. The majority of the French speaking people are intelligent to know what they sell in Canadian Tire, Best Buy, Toys R Us, etc. As to the French face of Quebec, we have seen it in the streets over the last few months.
  10. Drew posted on 06/21/2012 01:47 AM
    Companies should just close up and leave .
  11. steve posted on 06/21/2012 09:19 AM
    Just more never ending pettiness from the OQLF.Reacting to complaints? They are, the fanatical linguistic complainers! Shows a lack of respect? Ha,Ha.Keep it up, till Quebec goes completely down the sinkhole.If it hasn't already.
  12. king posted on 06/21/2012 10:57 AM
    it`s nice to know we are justifiably spending taxpayers money!!!! too bad hundreds of people will get sick or die because hospitals don`t have enough money which is being spent on the OQLF.......our roads are caving in and we have more riots than the rest of the world put together.....THANKS CHAREST now lets go corrupt a construction contract so you can put more taxpayers money in your swiss bank account
  13. monsieurjoe posted on 06/21/2012 12:16 PM
    Can someone please remind me of what's sold in Le Château? Maybe they need a little descriptor to remind Anglos of that they don't sell castles.
  14. Derpz posted on 06/22/2012 01:26 PM
    Quebec is a fascist province, this is getting ridiculous now, between STM workers refusing to give service because of a client speaking English to them (not just not speaking English to them but outright REFUSING to serve them), having these OQLF Nazis patrolling what language people use, the Liberal government or any government not protecting the interests of the anglophone or bilingual/english preference citizens of Quebec and lest we forget the corrupt police, corrupt construction workers and student strikes it's apparently clear that this province's interests are not that of other societies who focus more on ACTUAL issues instead of these fascists, and before anyone starts slamming, I'm not dogging or grouping all francophone Quebeckers being this way, but for the vocal minority/majority this is truely enough, something needs to be done about this province's attitude towards outsiders, or we may as well have a sign at an airport saying "Unless You speak French get out of our province" and refuse tourists altogether unless they are coming from France or the french speaking North African counrties as well as Haiti

    this is not a normal government, not good upstanding human beings, they are filth and this Nazi xenophobic mentality needs to end permanently
  15. Claude posted on 06/23/2012 04:08 AM
    In france kentucky fried chicken is still called ''KFC'' just like everywhere else in the world but here in quebec it's ''PFK''.

    Next thing any type of food or products with english on the packaging will be banned from quebec and only french websites and french programming will be viewed in quebec.

    Oh and also you will receive a $500 fine if you are caught speaking to your pets in english.

    This is from the mind of a Québécois some of us are intelligent to know english will always be important in the world and these people are just idiots who have nothing else in their lives.

    So to all my Québécois people wake up!!!!!!!!!
    1. Claude B posted on 06/26/2012 11:12 AM
      @Claude I was educated in English an consider myself very lucky. Being of French-Canadian descent, I would have no choice but to send my kids to French school if my parents had not had the fore-sight to send my sister and I to English school. You can't imagine how many French-only Quebecers tell me how lucky I am to be bilingual.

      I just don't see the point in being forced by the OLF to make French the predominant language. I wish as much effort would be placed in making this a fully bilingual province. That way it would ensure the survival of French and put an end to this stupidity.
  16. Stan posted on 06/23/2012 07:56 PM
    They can have the Fench face as long as the brain is English.
  17. Dan Boone posted on 06/25/2012 11:48 AM
    As a born and bred Montrealer, I am sickened by what the Governments of Quebec and Canada allow to go on in Quebec. Quebec is NOT special. I am a Canadian first and foremost, but I can't get service in English if I were to come back to where I was born,nor be able to read my driver's permit. The language laws have worked, no one will forget Quebec, the stupidity of Quebec will long be remembered.
  18. Vive le Quebec Libre! posted on 06/28/2012 11:32 PM
    We just returned from 2 weeks in the US so missed all of this hoopla. We look forward to leaving Quebec often in the summer/fall and eventually we look forward to leaving Quebec permanently.

    In the meantime We will avoid spending our $$$ in Quebec and we will shop in NH where there is no sales tax and only if absolutely necessary will we shop and pay sales tax in NY and VT. I wonder how much we will save by purchasing an RV in NH and leaving it in the US
  19. Murray posted on 06/28/2012 11:38 PM
    How come Metro Stores (not a national/international retailer and one based in QC was not ordered by the OQLF to put an accent on the e?

    Is there a double standard going on here?
  20. Tim posted on 01/10/2013 12:12 PM
    When will the government realize that no bill or law will save the french language/culture. It is the people that represent their culture. By imposing such laws that is killing the french language/culture. Fascism and racism is never the answer. I am french and I believe that this ridiculous.
showing all comments

News

You are seeing the 2 most recent blog posts.

News Videos

News Audio

Note about comments: Comments will not appear immediately after posting. Comments containing links or vulgar language and comments that are racist, sexist or offensive will not be approved.