Quebec to legalize doctor-assisted suicide

Posted By: Angelica Montgomery · 10/4/2012 11:03:00 AM

Quebec's new government plans to table legislation legalizing doctor-assisted suicide by this spring.

"We really feel that it is necessary to put forward such a possibility for people who, at the end of their life, are suffering in an unbearable manner," says social services junior minister Véronique Hivon.

She says the idea was part of the Parti Quebecois' election platform, and was also recommended by an all-party National Assembly committee last spring.

She says her bill will be based on that committee's report. It's guidelines said patients should only have access to the service if they are adult Quebec residents with a serious and incurable illness, and have given their express written consent.

"We're really talking about people who have unbearable suffering and who have no chance of improving their quality of life and whose death is really going to happen," says Hivon

likely to pass

Although the Parti Quebecois has a minority government, the CAQ, which holds the balance of power, has already said it supports the measure. The Liberals have not taken a position on the subject.

battle over jurisdiction?

Quebec has no power over the criminal code, which forbids doctor-assisted suicide.

However, Hivon is arguing that Quebec will be able to pass this law without Ottawa. "Quebec has jurisdiction over health and also over professional qualifications," she says. "So this gives us the confidence to introduce this medical aid in dying in our bill."

In order to be as thorough as possible, Hivon says the Parti Quebecois would also issue a directive to crown prosecutors to not enforce the part of the criminal code that bans doctor-assisted suicide, as long as a case fits the province's criteria.

It is unclear whether the Harper government would accept the Parti Quebecois' interpretation of the law.

photo of: Véronique Hivon

Leave a comment:

showing all comments · Subscribe to comments
  1. JamesR_1055 posted on 10/04/2012 02:30 PM
    Quebec's family physicians have been lobbying to get the right to put an end to patients' lives with doctor-assisted suicide for at least a few years now.

    With this latest move, the PQ and CAQ are bowing to a very influential and wealthy segment of the population.

    Quite frankly, it sends chills down my spine. Over the years, there have been a significant number of "miracle" cures, spontaneous remissions when a person who was in a coma or who was facing an almost certain death and in great pain suddenly became better and left the hospital. Any law which allows doctor-assisted suicide condemns these people to death since they will never live long enough to have that miracle cure.

    I know, I know. People will say this is so rare that it's neglible. In my life, though, I have personally known of two such cases. In one of them, the fellow was nothing but skin and bones. He was so far gone and in such pain that the most powerful medications still left him in agony as well as dazed and confused. He wanted to die. The only thing that kept him from taking out his rifle and pulling the trigger was the idea of his son finding him like that and knowing his dad had committed suicide. So, instead he toughed it out.

    One day, I met this man. He had no other options and so he agreed to let me pray for him and over him. Now, I'm no saint but I was all he had at that point. And so, I prayed over him and started a rosary novena. By the time I finished it, his doctor had called him up to tell him of a clinical trial for a new drug. This man was put on that trial and within less than a year was fully recovered with virtually no sign he had ever had the disease.

    Today, he is still alive and well and taking care of his family, including his son.

    My point is this: If we allow doctor-assisted suicide, then people like that man will very likely ask for it. They will be killed. And all hope of making a last-minute recovery and living their lives will disappear forever.

    Doctor-assisted suicide is a choice we as a society should not make. If we do make it, yes, many people who are suffering with very painful, likely fatal illnesses will no longer have to suffer that physical pain. But the trade-off is frightening. The trade-off is that we will be killing people who would otherwise have healed on their own or been candidates for new medical treatments. And, to top it all off, we will be making killers of our doctors. To call it murder is inaccurate and ungracious but it will still be homocide.

    Our physicians are healers, not killers. And when a person is very, very sick, the last gifts we can give them are our love and hope.

    Doctor-assisted suicide would snuff out lives - and it would snuff out hope.

    My friend is still alive today because he did not have recourse to doctor-assisted suicide.

    Please, please don't kill people like my friend.
    1. margaret goyette posted on 10/04/2012 11:02 PM
      @JamesR_1055 People in the late stages of terminal illnesses are not going to be candidates for "new miracle drugs", and if they do not live in big cities near medical centers or research centers to track such medications, they will not be seleced as candidates for experimental medications. YOU sit by someone in the last stages of ALS, cancer, Huntindon's Chorea and offer them your love and hope while they are suffering with extreme pain ,drowning in their own fluids, or starving to death because they had no choice but to suffer BECAUSE THEY HAVE NO CHOICE. I guarantee you that lack of choice and respect is more frightening for them.
  2. Terry posted on 10/04/2012 08:58 PM
    Great way for the government to save on pensions and health care. New cures are being found every day. Stick around and collect your pension. The money could be used for your children, grandchildren, or favorite charitiy. Bet the politicians won't be taking advantage of this doctor-assisted suicide.
    1. Geo posted on 10/06/2012 01:38 PM
      @Terry I wasn't planning to comment on this, but then I read your comment. You can't be serious....Do you actually believe what you wrote ? Let's see, where do I begin....
      Tell me what new cures you know of that have been found in the last year. According to you, there's a new cure found every day. Name just one.
      >>>Stick around ? LOL. In all my years I have never read a more ridiculous comment anywhere. You are either trying to be funny or really are one notch "below" in the evolutionary scale.

      Good luck to you. I hope you're not in a job where you have to make thoughtful decisions.

      It's obvious this level of discussion is WAY beyond your intellect.
  3. Elizabeth Di Blasio posted on 10/06/2012 10:00 PM
    Doctor assisted suicide is the commencement to a slippery slope- I am against it.

    It is murder. Where does it stop? Presently it is already happening in our hospitals-

    My brother was murdered 10 years ago in a Montreal hospital by his treating doctor-

    His treating doctor administered a drug called ' Propofol" this drug in turn brought

    him to cardiac arrest... the lady who lived with him had signed a DNA the same day
    that my brother entered the Emergency Room- 7 days later my brother was dead.


    The discharge summary states that the doctor in question had a 30 minute talk with my brother's companion and decided not to resuscitate him because he had dementia and was 80 years old. And so it was time for him to go.

    This happened 10 years ago... My brother had a large life insurance policy- someone was anxious to get her hands on it.

    Need I say more? More atrocities of this kind will happen ... Thousands of helpless people will be put to death- and there will be no fear now of retribution.

    With this new law one can only surmise that our society will become more and more
    callous- instead of becoming more compassionate.

    I have hospital documents to prove the veracity of this story...

    My brother still possessed "Joie de vivre" Horrific!







    ropofol ' and he was

    brought to cardiac arrest ... The hospital document states that the lady who lived

    with him had signed a DNR the day my brother entered the emergency room ....

    The doctor in question hurried his death and my brother became code 99 - that is the doctors' code- their language... Do Not Resusictate in less than a week - my brother was dead. As far as I knew my brother loved life ... he still had the joie de vivre...
    my brother was a bon vivant ...
showing all comments

News

You are seeing the 2 most recent blog posts.

News Videos

News Audio

Note about comments: Comments will not appear immediately after posting. Comments containing links or vulgar language and comments that are racist, sexist or offensive will not be approved.