Black man says racial profiling led to wrongful arrest

Posted By: Shuyee Lee · 10/30/2012 5:00:00 PM

A young black Montreal man has filed a complaint with the Quebec Police Ethics Committee after being arrested for a crime he didn't commit.

Nineteen-year-old student Mark Wiles Simpson was minding his own business and talking to his cousin in a park near the McDonald's in St. Laurent where he was going to start his shift when police jumped him, wrestled him to the ground, punching and choking him. Four officers were involved in the October 3 incident.

"I said what's going on, I didn't do anything. They weren't telling me, they weren't answering me, they weren't telling me why I was being arrested," Simpson told a news conference.

Turns out, they thought he was a suspect in the hold up of a nearby SAQ. But he was the wrong man, and police released him with no apology and charged him with obstruction of justice.

His mother Dionne Wiles can't believe it.

"Montreal police made him a criminal. His crime is being black and male," Wiles said tearfully.

One of Simpson's friends took a video of the incident which shows four officers on top of Simpson who is lying on the ground, shouting and not resisting. One officer who kept Simpson's friends and other witnesses at bay is heard saying, "He did something wrong, now he has to pay the police."

Simpson said the whole experience made him feel badly, humiliated and distrustful of police."

Fo Niemi, executive director of the anti-racism lobby group CRARR (Centre for Research Action on Race Relations), said this was only one example of a common occurrence.

"This is yet another case of "Any Negro Will Do," where police act on a vague race-based suspect description and arrests someone as if all black men look alike," Niemi said.

"We hear this kind of story happen very often: a vague suspect description and an innocent black person, usually a black male, is being jumped on and wrestled to the ground and they used force against him and in this case unfortunately, he ends up with a criminal charge which is beyond our comprehension."

The family wants an apology from the mayor and the police chief and also plans a civil rights complaint. Simpson said he decided to speak out publicly about his experience.

"I don't want them to do this again to any black male. I don't want it to happen, I want something to be done."

 

Photos: Shuyee Lee

Leave a comment:

showing all comments · Subscribe to comments
  1. fedup posted on 10/30/2012 03:58 PM
    No surprise here. The Police are reflection of the Quebec society. I don't think I have to elaborate.
  2. Geo posted on 10/30/2012 06:13 PM
    Let's see...an SAQ is held up and the police, in their "wisdom" proceeded to kick the crap out of the first black male they spotted. Personally, I would not have assumed that a man brave enough to hold up a liquor outlet would not have a better escape plan but rather hang out at a local McDonalds.

    This guy (just a kid) deserves an apology and alot of money for the humiliation.

    The entire police force needs a refresher course on BRAINS and common sense.

    Certainly, there are always a few bad cops. Most are good, but there are those special few...There was a word we often used in the '60's to describe these special types.......................
  3. Rudolph S posted on 10/30/2012 06:41 PM
    is that was it comes to now, the overzealous Policemen screwed up and now to hide there fault they charge an innocent man with obstruction of Justice...this stinks
  4. Joseph E. posted on 10/30/2012 06:54 PM
    Read the story, and feel real bad for Mark. As a young black male I can identify with the frustration. I know the law is the law and that police need to enforce it; but they can at least apologize when they get the wrong person. I hope Mark gets that apology.
  5. C.J. posted on 11/01/2012 10:28 AM
    What can we say...He fit the profile...That's what they say to me all the time when the have stopped me...
  6. Nelun Seneviratne posted on 11/02/2012 12:21 PM
    I was totally disgusted and truly appalled when I saw the video of this incident on PULSE news a couple of days back. It breaks my heart as a mother to watch the cruelty of the cops (this time, even female police officers) at this young, innocent, young man. Why, because he was black and a male - that was his crime - been born BLACK. When will the Police of Montreal ever learn to first make sure they know that they have the right person before they go punching and chocking innocent young people?
    An apology alone is not sufficient. This young man should be compensated not only for the humiliation that was caused by these over zealous cops, but also for the pain and trauma that was caused to him. He will never trusts cops again.
    I know this, as my son was a victim of racial profiling and I will never ever forget the injustice done to my son either.
    I wish this young man the very best for his future and wish to tell him that he should never be afraid to fight for his rights!!!
    After all, we live in a free, just and democratic society.
showing all comments

News

You are seeing the 2 most recent blog posts.

News Videos

News Audio

Note about comments: Comments will not appear immediately after posting. Comments containing links or vulgar language and comments that are racist, sexist or offensive will not be approved.