EXCLUSIVE: Incompetence to blame for man's death says victim's family

Posted By: Shuyee Lee · 11/2/2012 5:18:00 PM

A Lachine family is accusing Urgences Santé and the Lachine General Hospital of negligence and incompetence in the case of a 27-year-old man who died Sunday in hospital after collapsing during a soccer game.

Clarck Cadet was videotaping the soccer game at the Catalogna Soccerplexe in Lachine when one of the players, his friend Troy Elva, known as Nickey, collapsed. Cadet said it took as long as 15 to 20 minutes for the ambulance to arrive and then another 5 to 10 minutes for technicians to set up the equipment, realizing they didn't have the paddles for the defibrillator and had to go back to the truck to get some.

Cadet said they then followed the ambulance to the hospital, going through red lights and stop signs when the ambulance driver suddenly stopped, got out and told them they weren't an ambulance and not to drive so recklessly.

"We're losing valuable minutes of a man's life while they sit here and try to lecture me and scold me about driving," Cadet told CJAD News.

Elva was pronounced dead at the hospital. Cadet said the family is also upset because the doctor told the family they would stop resuscitation efforts without consulting them or giving them any options.

MUHC spokesman Ian Popple said in an email that in general, it's a medical decision based on specific patient situations upon arrival in the emergency ward and that care is discussed with patients and family when possible and where appropriate for admitted patients.

Urgences Santé said it would look into the matter.

Cadet said the whole situation was badly handled and based on incompetence.

"If they would have been more precise with their timing in getting there on time, if they had been better equipped, the outcome would have been different."

Photo: Clarck Cadet

Leave a comment:

showing all comments · Subscribe to comments
  1. Finsley nelson posted on 11/02/2012 07:39 PM
    We have lost a great friend that we all call family and even close as blood ,may God bless his soul and comfort his family in this time of sorrow,Nickey one day we all shalt meet again .REST IN PEACE MY BOY
  2. JJ posted on 11/02/2012 10:47 PM
    This really does not sound good. Something needs to be looked into here. We depend on the responses of Urgences Sante to assure that our loved ones get the possible care at the worst of times. It seems that like everything else in Quebec, Urgences Sante is busy playing the "judgement card" and acting according to their prejudices. Then will come the ultimate insult: an invoice for patient care.

    Ian Popple's comment makes absolutely no sense in thse circumstances. It is as if he is totally unaware of what is being said by those traumatized people who were in place when this young man collapsed. Somebody needs to get real with Urgences Sante.
  3. Arthur posted on 11/03/2012 02:28 AM
    Well lets see, they do not want to serve the English community, I guess not blacks either, and it seems Urgence Sante feels is better to be traffic cops than save a human life. This goes beyond incompetence. They should be fired, but the sad truth is they will more likely be promoted. Its about time we the public speaks out, this is simply not acceptable.

    My sincere condolences to the family in this time of grief.
  4. Elaine posted on 11/03/2012 10:06 AM
    Condolences to the friends and family of Mr Troy Elva, i pray that the creator may bless, sustain, guide and strengthen them always..

    I believe that the priority of the Urgence Sante crew is to get the patient to hospital ASAP...

    Stopping to lecture others on how to drive while a person in critical condition is in the ambulance should be a criminal offence...

    Is this proper conduct of the people that are given the responsibility to get us the medical help we need ASAP?...

    French, English, Alophones, etc, we are all people, we deserve to be treated with respect , we live, work, play and pay taxes in the society , i believe everyone deserve the same level of care...

    People of Quebec, is this the kind of society that we are comfortable living in, where some people do not get the proper care?

    Where some lives are not valued?

    Remember this quote " Silence in the face of evil is itself evil " (author unknown)
  5. Nady posted on 11/10/2012 09:44 AM
    this is my cousin and i know alot could have been done to save his life. I last saw and spoke to nickey for his dad's funeral in St Lucia, and now i gotta bury him. I dont know what will happen when i actual see his dead body. Our family lost you too soon. Our heart are heavy and we are weak. Life goes on but we can't get another like you. Once nickey laughed one had to laugh also joke or none. I still can't believe you gone until i see your body. And if that was a racial act on the ambulance workers part, god is in control.
showing all comments

News

You are seeing the 2 most recent blog posts.

News Videos

News Audio

Note about comments: Comments will not appear immediately after posting. Comments containing links or vulgar language and comments that are racist, sexist or offensive will not be approved.