The Bill 14 that still hangs in the balance

Posted By: Angelica Montgomery · 3/8/2013 3:59:00 PM

Despite the CAQ's vow to oppose parts of the bill, the future of some sections are still unknown.

For one, bill 14 will change the reference to "ethnic minorities" within the Charter of the French language to "cultural communities."

Law student Colin Standish, a vocal opponent of bill 14, says this is the most important section left, because ethnic minorities are protected under international law, while cultural communities are not.

"It would be more difficult to prove that you were an aggrieved ethnic minority if you don't have any title under domestic legislation."

Today, François Legault says that this change is small. "Most people talk about cultural communities. Even the words 'ethnic minorities' have a negative sound for some people," he says.

"I think it's not an important aspect of the law."

Mastery of French

The legislation also says students in English high schools and CEGEPs would have to show a mastery of French in order to graduate.

Some educators say they are already making efforts to offer more French schooling, although second-language education is more expensive and school boards are already experiencing cuts. 
 
"I think that services are not given right now to school boards, to newcomers," says Legault. He says he needs more information on what is intended in this section of the law.

Inquiry, search, seizure

Section 1.3 of the bill gives the minister, or anyone she delegates, the power to force companies, municipalities, or others, to testify before her, hand over documents, and take oaths.

Under the bill, those who fail to co-operate or sufficiently answer questions could be charged with contempt. It also provides the OQLF with the power to seize property.

The CAQ leader says he'll wait to hear from the Quebec bar association on the topic. "I'm not against it,  but I want to make sure that they don't give this power to some 'caribou' (party hard-liners)."

showing all comments · Subscribe to comments
  • 4
Comments are closed.
  1. Le Québécois posted on 03/08/2013 05:37 PM
    "It would be more difficult to prove that you were an aggrieved ethnic minority if you don't have any title under domestic legislation."

    The oppressed english minority of Québec that has more media exposure (pastagate) than the governement itself (trip to New-York) and has the support of a federal government willing and able to impose it's laws on Québec (constitution) and with institutions far bigger than itself in most cases (universitites).

    I would love to see the minorities getting in line to complain at the U.N. :
    -we have been tortured and killed
    -they cut our hands if we don't join the Jihad
    -our women are mutilated for religious purposes
    -we receive bombs everyday

    but the worse is actually going on in Québec :
    -we have to put french on our english signs and french has to be bigger...
    ... and we also have to pass a french test

    words alone cannot describe this level of oppression...
  2. Steven Chaimberg posted on 03/08/2013 05:52 PM
    What rot!!!! with a straight face, Francois Legault comes up wit the statement that "French will always be fragile"

    When Confederation occurred in 1867, Quebec was 80% French; in 2013, Quebec is over 80% French. The discriminatory legislation that is constituted by Bill 101 (and Bill 22 before it) is an absolute disgrace, and a denial of the compromise that was reached when Canada came into being. If Bill 101 had been adopted in 1868, it would have been ruled ultra vires and beyond the jurisdiction of the Quebec legislature. Non-francophones are absolutely without political power; all they have to "look forward to" is for their rights to be restricted, to a greater or lesser extent, depending upon which party in Quebec City is doing the squeezing!
  3. SandySpeaks posted on 03/08/2013 09:20 PM
    Changing “ethnic minorities” to “cultural communities” is dubious. François Legault says that this change is small. If it is so small, why does the PQ want to make this change?
  4. IMO posted on 03/09/2013 12:56 AM
    This law must be struck down in its entirety. CAQ = seperatists in sheeps clothing
showing all comments

News

You are seeing the 2 most recent blog posts.

News Videos

News Audio

Note about comments: Comments will not appear immediately after posting. Comments containing links or vulgar language and comments that are racist, sexist or offensive will not be approved.