Paul Rose a hero: Khadir

Posted By: Canadian Press · 3/14/2013 7:23:00 PM

Convicted terrorist Paul Rose, who died Thursday of a stroke, is best known as an architect of the 1970 October Crisis, which saw political kidnappings and murder and troops flooding into Quebec.

Now a member of the provincial legislature wants to honour him.

Amir Khadir, one of two members of the pro-sovereignty Quebec solidaire, promises to table a motion in the national assembly to that effect next week.

"This is someone who is significant to the independence movement,'' Khadir told The Canadian Press when asked about Rose's passing.

"You can share the reservations he had about his past in the FLQ, but no one can question his sincerity, his devotion, his integrity, his intellectual honesty.''

The Parti Quebecois government refused to comment on the death of Rose, 69, who was convicted in 1971 in the murder and kidnapping of then-Quebec vice-premier Pierre Laporte.

Khadir decried the government's silence about the death of Rose, who had supported Quebec solidaire in recent years.

"It shows once again the government's lack of courage,'' he said.

"This is an important figure in the Quebec independence movement and I invite all sovereigntist members, including ministers, to publicly express their condolences.''

The PQ has repeatedly distanced itself from the legacy of the October Crisis, one of the most tumultuous periods in Canadian history.

PQ founder Rene Levesque was scornful of the FLQ and its members.

He was appalled in 1981 when delegates to a party convention gave a standing ovation to Jacques Rose, Paul Rose's brother.

Paul Rose is best known to Canadians as leader of the Chenier cell of the Front du liberation du Quebec that snatched Laporte from the front lawn of his suburban home as he played touch football with his nephew on Oct. 10, 1970.

Laporte, who was also Quebec labour minister, was found strangled in the trunk of a car a week later, a day after the invocation of the War Measures Act that sent Canadian troops into Quebec to back up police who were carrying out mass arrests.

Rose died peacefully in a Montreal hospital surrounded by his wife and two children, as well as his sisters and brother Jacques, another former member of the FLQ.

"His son Felix and his daughter Rosalie read to him from 'Un Canadien errant' ('A Wandering Canadian'), the poems of Gerald Godin and Gaston Miron, and passages from ''Nous etions le nouveau monde" by Jean-Claude Germain,'' said Pierre Dubuc, who worked with Rose at l'aut'journal publication.

The selections reflect Rose's past as an activist for Quebec sovereignty and the promotion of French-language rights.

"A Wandering Canadian'' is a classic song written in the wake of the 1837 rebellions. Gerald Godin was a renowned poet who became a minister in the first Parti Quebecois government.

In recent years, Rose had been involved in the labour movement and advocated for convict rights. He was also a prominent speaker at a march last year in favour of Quebec students fighting tuition increases.

His nomination in 1992 as a provincial New Democratic Party candidate in a Quebec byelection prompted an objection by the federal NDP to the use of its name. Rose withdrew because he was still on parole and ineligible to run.

Rose's first forays into Canadian political issues involved more baton-swinging than ballot-casting.

In 1968, he was one of the rioters in the famed St-Jean-Baptiste Day clash that saw newly minted prime minister Pierre Trudeau staring down sovereigntist protesters from the reviewing stand as bottles flew.

Trudeau won the federal election the next day.

Rose was also was one of the organizers of the McGill francais demonstration in 1969 which called for the university to be transformed into a French-language institution.

That march erupted into clashes with police.

But it was his role in the 1970 October Crisis, one of the most tumultuous periods in Canadian history, that cemented Rose in the public consciousness.

His mugshot, a scruffy depiction of the labourer and sometimes supply teacher, was plastered everywhere until he was flushed out of an underground tunnel beneath a rural farmhouse in January 1971.

He and his accomplices, who included his brother Jacques, had threatened to blow everyone up.

Another image of Rose became iconic when he was photographed being taken to his arraignment.

Rose's free arm shot up in a clenched-fist salute but was yanked down by a burly provincial police officer as the cameras clicked.

Richard Meloche, a retired provincial police officer who was handcuffed to Rose's other arm at the time, told the editor of the Beststory.ca journalism site in an interview that the officer, Sgt. Albert Lisacek, almost broke Rose's arm.

"He really yanked it down,'' Meloche said.

"Rose didn't say anything but I could see he wasn't too happy.''

When he got to court, Rose yelled, "Vive le FLQ'' as his trial date was set.

Rose, who delivered a political rant even as his trial wound up, was not quiet in prison either, speaking out for convict rights and organizing strikes to get better education for detainees.

Although a Quebec government commission determined in 1980 that Rose was not present when Laporte was killed, he was not paroled until two years later.

He pursued his activism through l'aut'journal, which confirmed his death on Thursday, and through work with the Confederation of National Trade Unions and various fringe political parties.

Gerald Larose, the former president of the union, said no one would hire Rose at the time and he thought he had paid his debt to society.

"He was a man of conviction, he was an idealist,'' said Larose, who said he enjoyed Rose's company even if he disagreed with his terrorist tactics in the past.

Larose said if nothing else, Rose made an impact on Quebec society by showing that violence doesn't work in the pursuit of an objective.

"He paid dearly for a collective lesson,'' Larose said.

showing all comments · Subscribe to comments
  • 17
Comments are closed.
  1. Ray Gaudet posted on 03/14/2013 07:53 PM
    Whenever Khadir wants to join Paul Rose in hell, he can go right ahead.
  2. geo posted on 03/14/2013 08:29 PM
    Amir Khadir should be sent back from where he came from,POS
  3. jonico posted on 03/14/2013 08:32 PM
    Khadir's idea of a hero is certainly different from what most normal people think. Rose was a kidnapper & murderer - he died in peace unlike Mr. Laporte. If there is such a thing as hell, I'm sure Rose was granted the express pass there.
    1. Le Québécois posted on 03/14/2013 09:10 PM
      @jonico "Rose was a kidnapper & murderer"
      No he was not, he was not even there when it happened. And the "murder" was actually an accident (he choked when trying to escape) but they claimed he was executed not to lose face.

      He refused to tell the police he was not there and claimed to the end in solidarity that "the flq" did it.

      I do not condone any type of violence, it will always be bad, but you can't say lies as well.
    2. John F posted on 03/14/2013 09:22 PM
      @jonico jonico,

      I TOTALLY AGREE!!!
  4. wayne hawthorne posted on 03/14/2013 08:35 PM
    Is Quebec so bereft of heros that only losers are chosen? Montcalm, Riel, Trudeau.
    1. Le Québécois posted on 03/14/2013 09:14 PM
      @wayne hawthorne Montcalm and Riel is good, but Trudeau ?

      Because of Trudeau 500 people got arrested for having political opinions and 10 000 searches were made, ridiculous curfiews, tanks in the streets, etc.

      He may be Canada's hero for "putting Québec at its place" but he is certainly NOT Québec's hero !

      Can't wait to see the son try to do the same once again...
      Sovereignty is not that far after all...
  5. John F posted on 03/14/2013 09:10 PM
    Paul Rose was a murderer ( killer) who got away with a crime and Amir Khadir is one whom is nothing but a "traitor" to this country of ours and in my mind, should be DEPORTED out of here as soon as possible, but I know that it wont happen thanks to our "WIMPY" political system which accepts "GARBAGE" from wherever it comes from.

    My sincere sympathies to the family of Pierre Laporte for this injustice and for the the family of Paul Rose....no comment.
  6. Mike posted on 03/14/2013 09:13 PM
    Only a terrorist would support another terrorist. he should be put in jail for inticing hate, This guy is not even of French descent, he is clearly a outsider trying to stir the pot. The French and English (Of European descent) have been at eachothers throats since before Canada. Whenever the French fight with the English, it to me is like brothers and sisters fighting and sooner or later we will figure it out.Everyone else if you have nothing positive to bring to the table, ST%U.
  7. Joe posted on 03/14/2013 09:27 PM
    Just wondering who is the bigger piece of work here, Rose or Khadir?
  8. Stan posted on 03/14/2013 09:40 PM
    Why would the PQ distance themselves from the October crisis? The actors in this atrocity were sovereignist heroes, who just happened to be murderous criminals; you can be sure there are glasses of bordeaux being raised in toast to their legacies at every seperatist occasion. Maybe they can rename a street after him.

    Let them have their commemoration - and show the world yet again, for the second time in as many weeks, just how pathetic and disturbing this Quebec culture has become.
  9. Elisabeth Smits posted on 03/14/2013 10:26 PM
    This is as low they can go, a kidnapping killer becomes a Quebec hero? I heard it all! Get a live! All I can say is good ridance and some more of those separatist idiots should follow him real FAST!
  10. Terry posted on 03/14/2013 11:08 PM
    If Khadir was kidnapped and murdered by a terrorist group, would any members of his family consider the members of the terrorist group as being heroes.
  11. Mario Nov ati posted on 03/14/2013 11:34 PM
    Paul Rose was a criminal and after died is still a criminal.
  12. Josiey posted on 03/15/2013 12:36 AM
    A man of conviction, an idealist, who cares because he was a kidnapper and a killer!
    Khadir makes me angry. Thank God his party isn't in power or we would end up like Bosnia. How can someone be let into Canada that wants to destroy it? It is bad enough that the separatists that are born here are destroying our country. I wish we were more like the United states where they would all be tried for treason. How did our gutless Canadian government let things get so out of hand? We should have fought the fight years ago and things would be better now. I have no sympathy for Paul Rose, because he sure didn't have any for Mr. Laporte or his family. I think he should have stayed in jail until the day he died. He did not pay his debt to society or Mr. Laporte's family! You should be in jail for life and I mean your whole life when you plot to kill someone.
  13. JohnH- posted on 03/15/2013 12:36 AM
    I would like to preface my comments about the death of Paul Rose before I critique Mr. Amir Khadir's revisionist propaganda on the true validity of Paul Rose and the FLQ. First I would like to extend my condolences to his family and friends, I am sorry for your loss. I was taught at an early age not to speak ill of the dead because they are not here to defend themselves. At the same time to pay tribute to them is a matter of personal opinion that can be clouded by boisterous monomania. Which seems to be, (once again) Mr.Amir Khadir's juvenile assault for the public's attention. How tedious and bourgeois. Mr.Amir Khadir immigrated to Canada, Quebec, Montreal at the enlightened age of (10)-1971. He was immediately enrolled and indoctrinated into the Marxist-Leninist pedagogic structure that was the rigour at the time. He excelled under this regime and obtained scholastic honours. It seems that from the time Mr.Amir Khadir availed himself to the university education that was provided to him by his adopted country (Canada) and was bestowed his accreditation, there was a maladjusted transition into his rational existence. It would only be speculation on my part to understand or explain why Mr.Amir Khadir or anyone would demand a free and democratic society acknowledge and honour a trivial group of thugs responsible for , treason, murder, abduction, torture and extortion as distinguished human characteristics. As long as we hold people like Mr.Amir Khadir to accountability and fact we have exercised our right to be free.
  14. Thomas posted on 03/15/2013 12:59 AM
    A terrorist is a terrorist is a terrorist, and supporting terrorism is also a crime. The FLQ is the same as the PLO, the IRA, and the Taliban. They spread hate and use violence to fuel fear. Amir Khadir believes that Rose is a hero, Rose was a terrorist and Khadir is therefore a terrorist sympathizer which is a crime. Khadir should be stripped of his public office. Terrorism is not a bylaw infraction it is a federal crime and it is recognized by the UN and the World Court as a crime at the global level. Khadir should be treated as a terrorist sympathizer.
showing all comments

News

You are seeing the 2 most recent blog posts.

News Videos

News Audio

Note about comments: Comments will not appear immediately after posting. Comments containing links or vulgar language and comments that are racist, sexist or offensive will not be approved.