Charter won't survive legal fight: human rights commission

Minister Bernard Drainville opens charter hearings.
Angelica Montgomery/CJAD

Quebec's human rights commission says numerous provisions in the PQ's secularism charter are unlikely to survive legal challenges.

It is recommending the proposed legislation be heavily modified before it can be deemed compliant with the Quebec Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

The legislation as is would forbid public employees from wearing visible religious symbols including hijabs, turbans, kippas and larger-than-average crucifixes.

The commission said it was forced to publish its memoir and discuss its position publicly today because it was leaked to a local newspaper.

It says Bill 60 is a recipe for multiple legal challenges and that proposals to amend the charter of rights will only weaken it.

Commission head Jacques Fremont says its mandate was to analyze the proposed legislation and it concluded it won't bring the clarity the government is seeking.

He stops short of expressing any firm opinion on the legislation, leaving it up to elected officials to decide one way or the other.

The PQ government has insisted it won't back down on the values charter and is ready to make it an election issue if need be.

The plan has fuelled heated debates in the province since it was unveiled last year and some opponents believe the minority PQ could use identity as a wedge issue in an election campaign.

Government hearings on the values charter began Tuesday and are expected to last two months. As many as 200 individuals and groups are expected to appear.

Another organization has added its voice to the debate, calling on the government to replace Bernard Drainville, the cabinet minister who is spearheading the legislation.

Quebec Inclusif says Drainville doesn't understand the legal ramifications of Bill 60.

That group, a mix of federalist and sovereigntist voices opposed to the charter, says Justice Minister Bertrand Saint-Arnaud would do a better job.

Spokesman Remi Bourget says Drainville is rejecting irresponsibly by rejecting the legal opinions of the Quebec Bar and the human rights commission.

Leave a comment:

showing all comments · Subscribe to comments
  1. joeN posted on 01/17/2014 03:09 PM
    It's not meant to survive, it's meant to divide and conquer the voters who tend to sit on the fence in politics. They are gambling that they will get enough voters jump on their side to protect the Quebec identity, culture, language, poutine, st. hubert BBQ, you name it.
  2. Charlie posted on 01/17/2014 09:42 PM
    This political party is a party that:

    - Panders to a student body with promises Quebec cannot keep;
    - Insists that Quebec will have a balanced budget until it can no longer keep up pretenses;
    - Plays politics that promote division, with a consequence to visible minorities;
    - Refuses the opinions of august bodies that do in fact know better, specifically the bar and the human rights commission;
    - Is willing to amend its own charter of rights and subordinate it to its values charter;
    - Attempts to equate the Quebec Charter of Values with the Canadian Charter of Rights.;
    - Would win an election on the backs of Quebeckers.

    These people should not be governinig.
showing all comments

News Videos

Latest News

  • Several arrests in Montreal and Laval drug raids

    No less than eight separate police forces, including the RCMP, SQ, and Montreal and Laval forces, were involved in a series of drug raids across the Montreal area Wednesday morning. Read More
  • Playoff fever starts in Montreal

    Playoff fever is setting in for Montreal Canadiens fans. The first game of their best of seven first-round playoff series against the Tampa Bay Lightning starts at 7 p.m. tonight in Florida. Read More