Dorval teen should not return to live with mother: expert

Pre-sentencing arguments began Wednesday in the case of the Dorval teen who shot his brother in 2012.

The teen, whose name cannot be revealed under the youth protection act, has already served nearly one year in custody, and just over a month under house arrest with extended family.

Crown prosecutor Marie-Claude Bourassa told Judge Guy Lecompte Wednesday morning she would like the boy to be kept in open custody at a youth facility at least for another 18 months, followed by 18 months of probation.

She argued the boy continues to tell conflicting stories about the events when his brother was shot, as well as an armed robbery and shoplifting.

The stories he has told social workers and psychiatrists directly conflicts with the evidence that has already been presented in court.

The two experts who testified Wednesday, a social worker and psychiatrist, both believe the soon-to-be 14-year-old can be rehabilitated, but only with the right framework and support system.

Dr. Martin Giniac, the expert psychiatrist who testified, said the boy has certain troubles when facing violent scenarios.

“He needs to change the direction of his life,” he told the judge. But he said it’s still difficult to come up with a prognosis because of varying information from the boy regarding substance abuse.

“It’s still not clear because he can’t be honest,” he said. We need to clear this question otherwise he will be in a grey zone.”

Admission is the first step to rehabilitation, he said.

“[He] believes telling the truth will bring negative impacts in his life,” Giniac said. “We want his reflex to be to tell the truth.”

The doctor believes regular and intense therapy can treat the Dorval boy’s issues.

“His insight is superficial, he admits he was involved [in the shooting], but it would be deeper to acknowledge what factors led to his behavior,” the psychiatrist said.

“The boy’s mother is too emotionally involved,” the psychiatrist said answering questions if the boy could return home. That’s when tears ran down the mother’s face.

“He now has a strong support system [with the foster family],” he said. But the issue continues to be the boy’s attitude towards treatment and rules for success.

The pre-sentencing arguments are expected to last the rest of the week. 

Leave a comment:

showing all comments · Subscribe to comments
  1. Barcham posted on 02/12/2014 06:14 PM
    This kid should be locked up indefinitely. Mark my words that there will be other deaths at his hands if he is set free with the public still in the dark as to his identity. This must change and killers must be identified, no matter their age!!!
  2. Joseph posted on 02/12/2014 06:47 PM
    This boy can't tell right from wrong, I don't know about his up bringing, but he committed some very serious crimes at a young age. I don't think that he will change for the better.
  3. Nora posted on 02/13/2014 08:30 AM
    So he's an under aged violent chronic liar. Great. What an inspiring example for upcoming generations. Lock him up and lose the key for about 10 years.
showing all comments

Share this article:

News Videos

Latest News

  • West Island pedophile granted parole

    A Pointe-Claire man who had been sentenced to 10 years in prison for sexually assaulting a four-year-old girl, videotaping the crime, and posting photos of the assault on the Internet, has been granted parole. Read More
  • Mai Duong finds compatible cord blood donor

    After two months; Mai Duong, a 34-year-old Vietnamese woman who launched an international search to find a compatible stem cell donor to cure her leukemia has found some hope, a compatible umbilical cord blood donor, that could potentially save her life. Read More